Abuse at NY Dairy

Earlier this month, Mercy for Animals released a video (WARNING: disturbing footage) from an undercover investigation into the treatment of animals at New York state's largest dairy farm, Willet Dairy. The video is horrific and grotesque, from the conditions in which the cows live, to the manner in which they are treated. Some of the examples of abuse include:

- calves having their horns removed without anesthesia, where the worker places his fingers in the calf's eye to keep it still as the worker burns the calf's horns off,
- cows with severe wounds including prolapsed uteruses, untreated infections, swollen joints, all covered in manure,
- cows are shocked with metal prods as they are funneled into a truck from the pen, or vice versa, and
- cows have the ends of their tails "docked" without anesthesia.

This is a partial list of the actions that are, according to the investigator, commonplace at the dairy. The last of the abuses mentioned above, known as "tail docking," is a practice common at dairies across the country. Recently in California, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed a bill into law banning the practice of "tail docking." California Penal Code §597n, already banning the practice of docking horse's tails, was amended to include cattle.

Following in California's footsteps, and on the heels of the recently released MFA video, Assemblywoman Linda Rosenthal of New York Assembly District 67 proposed a similar bill banning the practice of tail docking.

The practice of tail docking is justified by proponents as necessary to preserve cleanliness of the cow's udder, higher quality milk production, and worker health. Though, according to several scientific, peer-reviewed journal articles (this is one of them), these justifications are unfounded. Still, approximately half of the 9 million cows raised for milk in the United States have their tails docked, according to a 2001 USDA survey. Approximately 1.2 million of those cows are raised in some 2152 California dairies, the nation's largest dairy producing state.

One of the reasons the welfare of cows has deteriorated is the dramatic consolidation of the dairy industry in the last 30 years. Small dairy farms (<30 cows), while representing nearly 30% of all producers in the country, account for a mere 1% of milk produced. In fact, the number of farms with less than 200 cows decreased by 30% in 6 years between 2000 and 2006. At the same time, the number of farms raising 2000+ cows doubled! In California, dairies with 500+ cows accounted for 88% of all dairy production in the state. For more statistics of the changes in the dairy industry, see the 2006 USDA study, here.

The treatment of animals raised in agriculture is an issue that is consciously and effectively hidden from the public. Given this latest video, with good reason. Nearly 10 billion animals are raised and slaughtered each year in the United States from human consumption. That is to say: we raise and kill for food the equivalent of almost one and a half times all human life on this planet, each year. Most of these animals are raised and/or slaughtered on large farms, run by major publicly traded corporations that treat these animals as commodities, reaching continuously to reach the highest efficiencies and economies of scale. As a result, the welfare of the animals is discarded in favor of lowering the bottom line further and further. The harsh eventuality of this industrialization of agriculture is now beginning to show itself, and stories like this one about Willet Dairy must compel us to react.

The silver lining here is the power that consumers hold in their pocket books. By choosing not to support large dairies where the majority of these animals are raised (and hence, abused), you will be taking a small step in the right direction. One small step may not be much, but two, three, four, 50, 100, 500, 1000, and more, eventually add up. Of course, choosing not to support dairies altogether would be a larger step, though not everyone is capable of doing that, including myself (for the time being). Thus, buying organic, rBGH-free milk, raised on small, local farms is a modest, yet valuable vote you can cast against cruelty to animals in agriculture.